Have you ever considered that the Prime Directive is not only not ethical, but also illogical, and perhaps morally indefensible?
Doctor Who Social Club @startrek.website FeaturedRetrospective Discussion | Doctor Who (2005) | 3x07 "42"
Canada @lemmy.ca Hegseth reportedly moves to restrict defence ties with Canada, but Ottawa sees no change
Hockey @lemmy.ca 6 Canadian cities announced as stops on PWHL Takeover Tour
Doctor Who Social Club @startrek.website Doctor Who editor reveals Russell T Davies' reaction to new cut of David Tennant episodes – and what made the process "terrifying"
Canada @lemmy.ca Canada's sport integrity watchdog introduces rules aimed at match fixing
Canada @lemmy.ca Canada looks to break Starlink's grip on Arctic military communications
Winnipeg @lemmy.ca New Red River sewer crossing operational; bypass removal begins on Fort Garry Bridge
STO Alliance @startrek.website Four New Ships for Lifetime Subscribers!
Star Trek Social Club @startrek.website 'Star Trek: Blue Shirts' Exclusive IDW Comic Reveal
Canadian Football League @lemmy.ca Blue Bombers fire head coach Mike O'Shea after 12 seasons
Canada @lemmy.ca Cadets being told to stand down as Canada adds billions to defence
Manitoba @lemmy.ca Wait for the most common diagnostic scans in Manitoba 'worse now than it ever has been': doctor
Canada @lemmy.ca Canada's national emergency alert system will sound off Wednesday for testing
Manitoba @lemmy.ca New middle-class tax cut coming next year, Manitoba government says in throne speech
Canadian Football League @lemmy.ca Trevor Harris signs contract extension with Saskatchewan Roughriders
STO Alliance @startrek.website Patch Notes for 11/17/26
Canada @lemmy.ca Canada and China announce new trade measures and cultural partnerships on Carney's 1st day in Shenzhen
Doctor Who Social Club @startrek.website A Legendary Evil? The Satan Pit Prequel
Canadian Football League @lemmy.ca The good, the bad, and the dumb of CFL commissioner Stewart Johnston's State of the League address
Canadian Football League @lemmy.ca Fajardo, Elks take down Alouettes, claim 113th Grey Cup









I suppose the fact that I find this to be the single most forgettable episode of modern Who means every time is like the first time, which is certainly something. This is another one that isn't exactly bad - it just exists.
I don't think the "real time" gimmick works for a single episode of TV - it's really not noticeable, let alone impactful. For it to be memorable, they'd probably have to do it in one continuous shot, "Adolescence" style, and I'm not sure that's feasible in sc-fi today, let alone 20ish years ago.
This episode also seems to try (and fail) to emulate "The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit". This is a little unfair, since it has half the runtime, but the end result is that it feels like it's about 85% exposition, and the ship's crew are pretty interchangeable blank slates.
But the Saxon plot inches a little further along, and Martha continues to be treated as a worthy companion, so that's nice.