Skip Navigation

Posts
3632
Comments
3503
Joined
3 yr. ago

Mastodon

Have you ever considered that the Prime Directive is not only not ethical, but also illogical, and perhaps morally indefensible?

  • I suppose the fact that I find this to be the single most forgettable episode of modern Who means every time is like the first time, which is certainly something. This is another one that isn't exactly bad - it just exists.

    I don't think the "real time" gimmick works for a single episode of TV - it's really not noticeable, let alone impactful. For it to be memorable, they'd probably have to do it in one continuous shot, "Adolescence" style, and I'm not sure that's feasible in sc-fi today, let alone 20ish years ago.

    This episode also seems to try (and fail) to emulate "The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit". This is a little unfair, since it has half the runtime, but the end result is that it feels like it's about 85% exposition, and the ship's crew are pretty interchangeable blank slates.

    But the Saxon plot inches a little further along, and Martha continues to be treated as a worthy companion, so that's nice.

  • It's obscured by the Yahoo URL, but this is a National Post article. Make of that what you will.

  • I would say Gamergate was a bit of a watershed, though, where that kind of toxicity became easily, prominently profitable.

    And yeah, it was over a decade ago, but we're still soaking in it, and I don't begrudge anyone for suddenly hitting their own personal limit.

  • What the heck, I've got a bit of time - here's what I could dig up on the various production companies/people involved:


    Hat Trick Mercurio

    This is a little tricky, since it's a joint venture. Hat Trick Productions has made a lot of stuff, across multiple genres. Jimmy Mulville is probably best known for comedy? On the other side, Jed Mercurio is a former RAF officer, and has produced mainly a series of medical and police procedurals, some of which have been quite acclaimed. He also wrote and directed a TV adaptation of "Frankenstein" in 2007. This could actually be a decent team for Doctor Who.


    World Productions

    Another well-established company that's made a lot of stuff over the years. Again, I'm seeing a number of procedural dramas, though there's some genre stuff sprinkled in. Without knowing the names of the actual writers involved, it's hard to draw any sort of conclusion, but it certainly seems like they could do the job.


    STV Studios

    More procedurals! Unfortunately, they have a bunch of sublabels, and I don't see any information on which, if any, of them are involved with the bid. The partner listed in the article, Screen Scotland, is a separate organization that promotes TV and film production in...Scotland. As interesting as the Scottish angle could be, this is the least interesting bid in my eyes, if only because there isn't much information available.


    BBC Studios

    I dunno, it's the BBC. As the article notes, they have a bunch of labels under them (17, according to Wikipedia), and there's no information on which are involved in the bid. There is a non-zero chance that the tender process is just a formality, and the series will end up going to BBC Studios when all is said and done.

  • Canadian Football League @lemmy.ca

    Trevor Harris signs contract extension with Saskatchewan Roughriders

    3downnation.com /2026/11/17/trevor-harris-signs-contract-extension-with-saskatchewan-roughriders/
  • STO Alliance @startrek.website

    Patch Notes for 11/17/26

    www.playstartrekonline.com /en/news/article/11584094
  • Yeah, the idea of "bring your own distributor" seems strange to me, but I'm a dummy. I suppose it makes sense if it comes with some kind of co-production arrangement.

  • There's one sentence near the end of the article that seems to be doing a lot of heavy lifting:

    At the start of 2027, there will be distribution conversations...

  • In sci-fi conspiracyland, all evidence must be twisted to support the original assumption.

    The fact that there are four bidders just proves that the franchise is doomed, I'll work out how later.

  • This confidence would be based on the pitches that we aren’t privy to, I suppose.

    And I'm sure a lot of it comes down to boring stuff like, "do you have studio space," and, "can you manage the budget effectively?"

  • I'm not going to pretend to be very familiar with any of these names, but it will be exciting to get an injection of new blood, rather than continually passing the show between the same three guys.

  • Canada @lemmy.ca

    Canada and China announce new trade measures and cultural partnerships on Carney's 1st day in Shenzhen

    www.cbc.ca /news/politics/canada-china-carney-xi-9.7424608
  • If commissioners were capable of that sort of self-reflection, Gary Bettman would have retired decades ago.

  • Oh, that's a bit of a relief - I think those webcasts were difficult-to-impossible to get outside of the UK back then?

  • On the one hand, I'm glad the DW team is putting in work to keep things alive.

    On the other hand...wow, this looks like it was made on half a shoestring budget.

  • Doctor Who Social Club @startrek.website

    A Legendary Evil? The Satan Pit Prequel

  • Canadian Football League @lemmy.ca

    The good, the bad, and the dumb of CFL commissioner Stewart Johnston's State of the League address

    3downnation.com /2026/11/13/the-good-the-bad-and-the-dumb-of-cfl-commissioner-stewart-johnstons-state-of-the-league-address-2/
  • Yeah, it became pretty apparent in the second half that the Elks were playing the better overall game.

  • Canadian Football League @lemmy.ca

    Fajardo, Elks take down Alouettes, claim 113th Grey Cup

    www.tsn.ca /cfl/article/fajardo-elks-take-down-alouettes-claim-113th-grey-cup/
  • Special introduction by Satan himself!

  • Yeah, "Genesis" is exactly what I had in mind. I think this episode's "road not taken" idea to be marginally less silly than TNG's "the DNA has recombined to an earlier lifeform" one, so that extremely low bar has been cleared!

  • Also, I forget if it’s ever explained how Lazarus has dormant scorpion genes that he could be (d)evolved into/out of/from. The whole thing is fairly nonsensical, even for a Doctor Who episode.

    There's a handwave about the dormant genes representing an evolutionary path not taken, which...yeah, it's nonsense, but maybe I'm just grading it on a Star Trek curve, because I actually don't mind it!

  • It's not the most forgettable episode of the revival (more on that next week), but it's close.

    It's not bad, really, but the plot is so threadbare that Lazarus being hauled away in the ambulance seems like a natural end point, even though there's a fair bit of episode remaining.

    It's a really good Martha episode, though. She gets to be a scientist, she gets to be a doctor, she gets to be an action hero, and she gets to grow a backbone and stand up to the doctor. As a resolution to the "unrequited love" angle, it's quite effective.

    It's a pretty bad Tish episode, though. Showing her standing up to the creepy advances of her wealthy and powerful boss, only to become willing to acquiesce to them once he's younger was...certainly a choice that they made. Some twenty years later, it's hard to imagine that they ever would go that route were they to make it today. It doesn't help that Mark Gatiss does not have the magnetic charisma required for this to be remotely believable.

    The episode also kicks the Harold Saxon arc into high gear. It's interesting that the Master has an interest in Lazarus's work - I suppose it must have something to do with the Toclafane, but I can't remember if that's ever made explicit. I never noticed before that the logo of Lazarus's company is clearly (incomplete) Gallifreyan script, which is neat. I don't think you can call it foreshadowing, because I don't think we've seen Gallifreyan script at all before now, but the wiki tells me the same logo is later seen in the Master's ring, with the missing bits filled in.

    And of course, it must be said that this episode has some of the dodgiest CGI of the series so far. They probably would have been better off with a puppet. It's also odd that they didn't seem to model the creature after Mark Gatiss at all (or if they did, they missed the mark quite badly).

  • I dabbled in the late 90s, but ultimately it wasn't for me. The Trek sets look great, though - good luck on your journey!

  • Me too, to be honest, but this channel is usually worth a watch.