Stylistically, it's spectacular. Plot and theme are both weak, but a good introduction to the characters. I do appreciate how much TOS tribute it fits into the package.
Into Darkness intoduced more classic Trek anti-militarization messaging, but the story was dreadful, and somewhat presaged what happened with Abrams and the final Star Wars film.
Beyond was the best Trek film of that era but, of course, Abrams wasn't involved in it.
But hand her a great work of alien literature, and it's just a bunch of squiggles.